What belongs in acquisition cost

Define paid customer acquisition cost (CAC) as the cost of acquiring new customers through paid campaigns: attributable media spend plus campaign costs required to run those campaigns. Media includes spend on platforms such as Google, Meta, TikTok or affiliates. Campaign costs can include directly assigned creative production, campaign-specific landing pages and agency or freelancer fees. Use the same VAT treatment, currency and reporting period every time; do not mix VAT-inclusive costs with VAT-exclusive revenue.

Exclude fulfilment, postage, packaging, product cost, refunds and payment fees. These affect order or product profitability, not the cost of buying the customer. Exclude general overhead such as rent, salaries and software subscriptions unless you are deliberately analysing total marketing or operating costs. Discounts should be reported separately rather than silently added to media spend. If a campaign targets both new and existing customers, allocate only the defensible new-customer share to paid CAC and document the method.

The CAC calculator is useful for setting out the inputs consistently. Keep these measures separate:

Acquisition measures answer different questions
MeasureWhat it includesWhen to use it
Paid CACNew-customer media and directly assigned campaign costsDeciding whether paid acquisition economics are acceptable
Blended CACTotal acquisition spend divided by all new customersAssessing the whole acquisition programme, including unattributed sources
MERTotal store revenue divided by total advertising spendChecking overall advertising efficiency, not the cost of one customer

First-order margin as a ceiling

First-order contribution is the hard ceiling for paid CAC. Calculate it from realised revenue on the delivered order, less product cost, fulfilment, payment fees, packaging, discounts and any other costs that occur because that order was placed. If a £42 haircare order leaves £17 after those deductions, £17 is the maximum first-order CAC before the order contributes nothing. It is a break-even limit, not a recommendation.

A practical CAC target normally sits below that ceiling. For illustration only, if the store needs £5 of first-order contribution to cover operating overhead and profit, the target CAC in the example is £12 (£17 ceiling − £5 required contribution). The right target depends on the margin the owner needs, available cash and how quickly ad spend must be recovered; the ceiling only answers whether the first order is economically viable.

Cash payback is a different measure. It asks when the cash generated by an acquired customer has recovered the CAC, rather than asking how much contribution the first order can spare. A £17 CAC against £17 of first-order contribution reaches first-order payback at zero surplus, while a £12 CAC leaves £5. Do not treat those as equivalent targets. ORVX calculates contribution from the store’s cost model and can report contribution after advertising by product and collection. Use the CAC calculator to test the ceiling with your own order economics.

What each CAC measure is for
MeasureUse it to answerDecision
First-order CAC ceilingCan this order break even?Do not exceed it
CAC targetWhat can we afford while retaining contribution?Set the operating limit
Cash-payback CACHow quickly is acquisition cash recovered?Manage cash timing

Worked example with sample numbers

This example is illustrative. It uses sample numbers for a haircare store selling in the UK. They are made up to show the method, they are not a benchmark, and your own figures will differ.

Formula: Ceiling = margin per order x orders per customer / target ratio.

Sample numbers: the most you can pay for a customer
Orders per customerMargin earnedCeiling at a 3:1 target
1.0£16.30£5.43
1.5£24.45£8.15
2.0£32.59£10.86
3.0£48.89£16.30

Run the same sum with your own numbers in the free calculator, or browse guides for sellers in the UK and more haircare guides.

General information only: tax, duty and import rules change and depend on your situation, so check with an accountant or the official source before acting.

Eligible Shopify stores can see these numbers for their own store through the Founding 10,000 offer.

How repeat orders change the limit

Repeat orders can support a higher lifetime acquisition limit, but they do not remove the first-order cash ceiling. Treat the two measures separately: the first-order limit tells you what the initial sale can fund; the lifetime limit tells you what the customer may contribute after repeat purchasing.

For illustration only, suppose a delivered first order contributes £18 after product, fulfilment, payment and other variable costs. A planning forecast expects a second-order contribution of £12 from 40% of customers and a third-order contribution of £10 from 20%. Expected later contribution is (£12 × 40%) + (£10 × 20%) = £6.80. A forecast lifetime contribution is therefore £24.80, before allowing for timing, refunds, overhead and uncertainty. That may support a planned CAC above £18, but only if the business can fund the initial loss and wait for those later orders.

The evidence standard matters. A forecast uses assumed repeat rates and order margins, so it is useful for scenario planning and testing a proposed limit. An observed cohort limit uses customers acquired in a defined period, then measures their actual delivered-order contribution and repeat rate over time. Use the forecast when deciding what to test; use mature cohort results when deciding what limit the store can defend. ORVX shows customer-level profitability and repeat behaviour, helping separate these views without treating an assumption as realised profit.

Two acquisition limits answer different questions
MeasureUse it forEvidence
Forecast lifetime limitPlanning a test or setting a provisional CAC targetAssumed repeat rate and contribution
Observed cohort limitApproving a durable limit based on actual customersDelivered-order contribution from tracked cohorts

How to read the worked example

Read the worked example as a sequence, not as a benchmark. Start with the selling price actually realised on a delivered order, then subtract the order’s product cost, fulfilment, payment fees and other included variable costs. What remains is contribution before advertising. That contribution sets the first-order CAC ceiling: spending above it means the order is unprofitable before any future behaviour is considered.

Next, apply the repeat-order adjustment separately. Expected contribution from later orders can support a higher lifetime acquisition target, but it does not increase the cash available to fund the first purchase. Use the first-order ceiling when deciding whether an acquisition can pay back immediately; use the adjusted lifetime measure when evaluating customer quality and retention. Keep the same treatment of discounts, returns and costs throughout the calculation. Enter your own realised order data in the CAC calculator, and treat the output as a decision input for your store, not a universal UK haircare benchmark.

Tracking the number by channel

Track three versions of the number, because each answers a different question. Platform-reported CPA is the ad platform’s spend divided by the conversions it attributes to a campaign. Use it for bidding and campaign diagnostics, but do not treat it as the store’s final CAC: platforms may count existing customers, use different attribution windows, or report conversions that do not match delivered new-customer orders.

Blended CAC is total paid media and required campaign costs divided by all new customers acquired through paid channels in the same period. It is the right number for judging the store’s overall acquisition economics. Cohort-based CAC assigns spend to customers acquired in a defined period, then follows that cohort’s repeat orders and contribution. Use it when assessing payback and retention, not when making a same-day bid change.

  • Keep channel, campaign, customer and attribution definitions fixed: specify whether CAC includes prospecting only or retargeting, define a new customer consistently, and use the same attribution window and reporting dates. Otherwise, a falling platform CPA can simply reflect broader attribution rather than cheaper acquisition.
Which CAC measure to use
MeasureBest used forMain limitation
Platform-reported CPACampaign and bid diagnosticsDepends on the platform’s attribution and conversion definition
Blended CACStore-level budget and profitability decisionsDoes not show retention by acquisition period
Cohort-based CACPayback and repeat-purchase analysisNeeds enough time for the cohort to mature

Sources

How this page was made: drafted with AI from a brief, then checked by automated rules for arithmetic, sources and duplication. The sample numbers were calculated, not reported.